"*" indicates required fields HiddenSource [Hidden] What is RRI ? Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) aims to encourage societal actors to work together during the whole research and innovation process to better align its outcomes with the values, needs and expectations of society. Understanding the benefits of RRI is crucial to furthering inclusivity, collaboration and transparency in systems. This needs to be built upon, to deepen understanding of whether and how RRI leads to societal, democratic, scientific and economic benefits, and to provide stakeholders with user-friendly yet advanced tools that help their efforts to improve the outcomes of R&I. This tool draws on a wide range of sources and rich discourse around Responsible Research and Innovatio to provide the foundation of a system that can specifically address the needs of its user base. Its theoretical underpinning is the RRI maturity model (Stahl, Obach, et al., 2017) which explicitly set out to synthesise different perspectives on RRI with a view to providing an overarching perspective on the level of RRI maturity across projects or organisations. Crucially, it combines the EPSRC vision of RRI as expressed in the AREA framework with the highly influential view of RRI as proposed by the European commission that emphasises six different keys (gender, science education, open access, ethics, public engagement and governance).HiddenDate [Hidden] HiddenFirst Name of Assessor [HIDDEN] HiddenLast Name of Assessor [HIDDEN] What is the name of your Project?*This is used as a descriptor for you to keep track of your projects as part of the ORBIT RRI suite of tools. Please detail the use case for this projectFor more information please see the following link https://www.usability.gov/how-to-and-tools/methods/use-cases.htmlSustainable Development Goals The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were created by the United Nations to be universal goals, targets and indicators that UN member states are expected to use to frame their agendas and political policies over the next 12 years. This tool uses the Sustainable Development Goals as a widely adopted measure of social ‘goods’ and therefore a useful metric against which to measure the potential impact of a technology and assess the level of required responsible innovation work. The ‘impact’ encompasses both positive and negative impact - for example GM crops that are beneficial for increasing food supply but may have a negative impact on the environment.Select the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG's) that, in the future, might be positively or negatively affected by the technology developed by your project.Please choose as many as you believe are relevant. For more information please click the following link https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/?menu=1300 No Poverty Zero Hunger Good Health and Wellbeing Quality Education Gender Equality Clean Water and Sanitation Affordable and Clean Energy Decent Work and Economic Growth Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure Reduced Inequalities Sustainable Cities and Communities Responsible Consumption and Production Climate Action Life Below Water Life on Land Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions Partnerships for the Goal HiddenNumber of Selected SDG's [Hidden]Evaluating the Impact When thinking about the impact on the Sustainable Development Goals can you indicate if the impact is either positive or negative. Also, when considering the impact is it possible at this time to provide a numerical level of impact on the Sustainable Development Goal and, if so, can you provide a source (report, journal or citation) for this quantified impact? No PovertyWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Zero HungerWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Good Health and WellbeingWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Quality EducationWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Gender EqualityWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Clean Water and SanitationWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Affordable and Clean EnergyWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Decent Work and Economic GrowthWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Industry, Innovation and InfrastructureWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Reduced InequalitiesWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Sustainable Cities and CommunitiesWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Responsible Consumption and ProductionWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Climate ActionWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Life Below WaterWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Life on LandWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Peace, Justice and Strong InstitutionsWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*Partnerships for the GoalsWhat type of impact does your Project have on this Sustainable Development Goal?* Quantified Positive Impact Unquantified Positive Impact Quantified Negative Impact Unquantified Negative Impact Please explain why you feel this Sustainable Development Goal is affected and where possible cite your sources.*HiddenNo_QuantifiedHiddenNo_UnquantifiedHiddenInnovation Potential 1 [HIDDEN]HiddenInnovation Potential 2 [HIDDEN]HiddenInnovation Potential 3 [HIDDEN]HiddenInnovation Potential 4 [HIDDEN]HiddenInnovation Potential 5 [HIDDEN]HiddenCalculated Innovation Potential [HIDDEN]Technology Readiness Level To be effective, RRI needs to be embedded in the research process, but we posit, at an appropriate level of intensity, proportional to the stage that the research is attempting to reach. Technology readiness level is one development pathway for new technologies. These give a common reference point when considering the level of development of a given technology has achieved.Please select your target Technology Readiness Level at the end of your ProjectFor more information on Technology Readiness Level please click the following links : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=in4TnQZGYj4 or https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technology_readiness_level#European_Commission_definition TRL 0 : Idea. Unproven concept, no testing has been performed. TRL 1 : Basic Research. Principles postulated and observed but no experimental proof available TRL 2 : Technology Formulation. Concept and application have been formulated TRL 3 : Applied Research. First laboratory tests completed; proof of concept. TRL 4 : Small scale prototype built in a laboratory environment (“ugly” prototype) TRL 5 : Large scale prototype tested in intended environment. TRL 6 : Prototype system tested in intended environment close to expected performance. TRL 7 : Demonstration system operating in operational environment at pre-commercial scale. TRL 8 : First of a kind commercial system. Manufacturing issues solved. TRL 9 : Full commercial application, technology available for consumers. Expert RRI Review Please share your research use case and SDG impacts with colleagues from as many different research domains as possible. Consider their perspectives and whether it is justified to increase the RRI Intensity Level.Do you, your team or your peers think that the technology might have the potential to pose significant risk or benefits which are not encompassed by the Sustainable Development Goals ?For example does it pose existential risks, might it exhaust global resources, or potentially limit human flourishing? The Ethics Self-Assessment developed by the European Commission for the purposes of Horizon 2020 provides guidance for the ethics issues involved in research. https://erc.europa.eu/sites/default/files/document/file/EthicsSelfAssessmentStepByStep.pdf Please select ...YesNoCan you give more information on why you think your project might have the potential to pose significant risks or benefits beyond the SDGs?HiddenRIL 5Used when the IP is 5HiddenRIL 5IP>2 IP<5 TRL=9HiddenRIL 4IP>2 IP<5 TRL >4 TRL <9HiddenRIL 4IP=2 TRL >6HiddenRIL 3IP>2 IP<5 TRL>2 TRL<5HiddenRIL 3IP=2 TRL>4 TRL<7HiddenRIL 3IP=1 TRL=9HiddenRIL 2IP>2 IP<5 TRL>0 TRL<3HiddenRIL 2IP=2 TRL>2 TRL<5HiddenRIL 2IP=1 TRL>2 TRL<9HiddenRIL 1IP=0 TRL<3HiddenRIL 1IP=1 TRL<3HiddenRIL 1IP=2 TRL<3HiddenCalculated RRI Intensity LevelHiddenSpider Graph - RISK [Hidden]HiddenSpider Graph - NO RISK [Hidden]HiddenRIL for the Spider Graph [Hidden]
